Broken – What Should have Been The Conversation

I typed this up just a couple weeks after the discard/breakup/whatever you want to call it in November. I wanted to remind myself of what I felt like at the time. As I never got to use my voice.

Broken is a story that is best read Chronologically to start from the beginning – Prologue

I typed this up just a couple weeks after the discard/breakup/whatever you want to call it in November. I wanted to remind myself of what I felt like at the time. As I never got to use my voice. Obviously I confronted her recently and she got a a very condensed version. This was before I knew what lied underneath her behavior. When I thought she was still a human being. I chose to take the red pill. – The terms “red pill” and “blue pill” refer to a choice between the willingness to learn a potentially unsettling or life-changing truth, by taking the red pill, or remaining in contented ignorance with the blue pill.

I think it’s a fascinating moment in all this. As I read it again I pretty much noted all the narcissistic behaviors. But didn’t think of her as one. I knew what she was doing and what she was targeting. I just didn’t know why. This is the problem with that abusive behavior. You see it but there are no answers. The now answers part is what compounds the abuse. And that is what is hard for people who have never experienced narcissistic abuse have a hard time understanding.

There have been signs, will share more on this soon, that are tough to ignore that I need to use my voice and confront this beyond the 5 minutes I took a few weeks ago. I don’t really want to but it feels more ‘necessary’ than I thought. And today I am giving that heartbroken Matt his voice from back in Nov/Dec. The one he should have been able to use. To tell the person that Broke him what they deserved to hear…

Hailey- I never understood the reason why you never wanted to break up with me in person. I think I understand now. I hold you accountable. For the way you treated me, for the things you said we would do, for the things you told to me. Like loving and adoring me. It’s hard to reconcile all this especially this last time. I don’t think you can face it. You are ashamed and you should be.

I know you think I was tough but being held accountable and saying your words meant something to me is normal. I just wanted to know why. It has always been about why with me. I love you so much and couldn’t fathom treating you with anything less than love. Even if you no longer wanted me.

I guess I never got over last December when you first broke my heart when you dated and slept with someone else at the worst moment of my life. I did forgive you but that was the first time I really doubted your intentions with me. Certainly when you left again for James and your kids back in March I was upset but could understand it more. But that was a tough few months leading up to that I never really settled with you. You were so uncertain about life during that time. You were in your head. So 2 years waiting to be able to be with you and when our time came. It was not great.

It took me months to get over you. I was moving on but always thought you might be there in the future. I knew you wouldn’t be able to sustain a relationship with him. I was not expecting you back though in July. When you came in and told me that you missed me and loved me. And that it was a living hell. You told me to wait. You knew you couldn’t ask fully but that and our subsequent dynamic told me you wanted me to.

Those following weeks I caught the old glimpse of you. But you did something reminiscent of your time with me before. You were vague about your plan and our future. You were never this way when you were fully invested in me. I wasn’t even sure your future included me. So i began to ask and you may think even pester. But I had been waiting for you for soooo long. And i had to trust you wouldn’t break my heart in such a short time.

After just a few months I saw that you began to start living a little bit of the single life. Going out late with girlfriends, being social. And when i pressed you on it. You told me life was so tough and it was so hard. You just had nothing left to give me. I didn’t buy it and with good reason. I had an affair with you for 19 months i knew exactly what you can give. But as usual I gave you the benefit of the doubt and space. I didn’t hear from you for 2 weeks and then you appear on a dating app. I mean no conversation no nothing. My heart was still with you and you knew that. It hurt so bad.

When I called you out on it. You were defensive and blew it off. I had no idea at that point where we stood but i knew you weren’t in the mood to talk to me. So I left you alone. Then a few weeks later I started seeing your car everywhere near where I live. You may think I am stupid but leaving your car there was intentional. It was meant to draw me into some interaction. And you gave that up when the second day I saw it I just asked to talk to you. And you said “I am not where you think I am” it’s a dead giveaway you were expecting to hear from me.

I don’t know what the purpose was except when you refused to have a conversation you said “not now” I had been suspecting that you had started dating anyways. But it seems that you are seeing someone regularly. In my neighborhood. This was awful enough to begin with but my god a couple streets away. When you said “I am sorry the way things ended” in a single text as if we had dated for a couple months I was heartbroken. I cried like someone died. Not only were you ending things, but you are giving what I waited 2.5 years for to someone you just recently met. Overnights, Time, Fun. All that i ever asked from you. And for some reason 3 separate times you couldn’t give me. After all that we had been through to get there.

In the process of our break up, if you want to call it that, you were cruel. Your last message was so cold. Not wanting to be “associated with my separation”, Telling me “You will be fine”, Then saying “I will not avoid you”, but you had been for 6 weeks, you said I will say hi. As if I am some acquaintance. You wanted to put the past behind you. And you think you do that by pretending like I never existed? That’s not how it works. You never said, I am grateful for your love. Or you are an amazing person but… nothing loving or soft like I had meant something to you. It was cold and unnecessary.

I don’t know why you would do that. I don’t know why you would then troll my soon to be ex-wife liking her posts on social media. We had discussed this and it doesn’t reconcile with not wanting to put the past behind you. It was hurtful to me as I don’t want the reminder of you right now. I also know you have been driving home from your overnights around the time I have been going back home from my morning routine. You know this window. I know it’s intentional. But why? It’s not a coincidence we passed each other 6 times in 2 weeks.

If you are done… let me be done in peace. It is going to take me a long time to get over you. I sent you a sweet letter and asked for space and you insisted on passively aggressively making me aware of your presence and basically saying “no”. I will never understand this. Are you throwing your new situation in my face. Is this something I deserve? I know it isn’t but these are questions only you can answer. I know you would deny that the social media thing and the drive bys are doing what you always do. But I know better… I know you better than I know just about anybody.

At the end of the day my heart is shredded for all the reasons mentioned above but none more than the simple reason… I loved you. Probably still do. I will forgive you in time. But I will never forget this year and how terribly you treated me. Coming back and asking me to wait and within 3 months dating someone else. Before you even left home. How many men will you do this to? You came to me before you left James, you went to someone else before you left me. You have unresolved relationships all over the place. You aren’t the victim Haley but you are leaving a trail of them.

…That last part of forgiving her. Probably not going to happen. When I realize how all intentional everything was and how she toys with my life like a game. It’s truly unforgivable. We will see. At this point it’s more about letting go than forgiveness.

Author: Matt

Hi, I’m Matt. Just your average uneventful guy. Dedicated Dad, emapth, and nurturer. Going through something I couldn’t possible ever thought possible. My story is called Broken. About an affair at the end of a long marriage and how ultimately I experienced the worst heartbreak of my life. It's honest, raw, and a little bit entertaining. I hope to share my story so people can learn while being therapeutic for myself.

9 thoughts on “Broken – What Should have Been The Conversation”

  1. This is an incredibly powerful statement…”You aren’t the victim Haley but you are leaving a trail of them.” Even if you never send this to her (you could easily leave it in an envelope on her car), I hope putting this on paper, giving yourself a voice, helps you to find closure.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I know they always say to move on you have to forgive, but I truly feel a lot of these people don’t deserve forgiveness. You didn’t deserve what happened, you weren’t a dick to your wife, you did everything you could to help your family move onto the next chapter and support them. You were more than understanding and loving and kind and patient with Hailey and her chaos. Though I don’t think you’ll ever forget your time together or what she put you through, I hope in time you’re able to let go of the anger, the disappointment and hurt. One day you’ll find someone who will give you what you ask and in return you will give her more than you ever gave her. Though it may feel a lifetime away, take this time to heal your heart and your soul. I should take my own advice huh? But I know how hard that is especially for someone as empathic as you. Sending you so many many hugs my friend

    Liked by 2 people

    1. We all could benefit from our own advice most of the time. I appreciate all this. I have already begun to let go of the anger in terms of what happened in our relationship. What has happened recently with the continued antagonization is just pissing me off. And driving me towards action.

      Really there are so many sweet things in your comment just… thank you.

      Liked by 2 people

  3. I am sorry you’ve had to go through this. Infidelity and narcissistic self-absorption are cruel. I’ve been there, and yes, forgiveness is key. Forgiving yourself, that is.
    I beat myself up for so much that was not my fault. “If only I’d done this.” “Why didn’t I do that?” And then I was hard on myself for not healing faster. Fuck. That. Bullshit. You do whatever you need to do to heal. Someone else’s fucked up personality and behavior choices are 100% owned by them.
    Keep writing, processing, and being kind to yourself. Hang in there.💜

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you! Feeling better… this is a little bit of purging all that stuff. It is hard as an empath it is always about “I could have…” But I think you are right at this point it is about forgiving myself. It is a bit humbling and humiliating about letting someone manipulate you like that. Thankfully my heartbreak is resolving itself almost on cue 6 months. But then yes hard on not healing faster. Just an ugh all around.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

HG Tudor - Knowing The Narcissist - The World's No.1 Resource About Narcissism

Know everything about narcissists from the world's no.1 source. A narcissist himself.

The Hot Goddess

Reimagining Midlife. Change Your Life to an Authentic Life Over 50

Onward & Upward

A blog about life, about moments that we all go through in life, but find away through.

Jaycee Dean

Power in words

The Quiet Storm

Buyer beware it's never all rated PG!!!!

Praying for Eyebrowz

Doing the best I can with what I have

Corrupting Mrs Jones

Often unfiltered thoughts.

Mitch Teemley

The Power of Story

A Season in my life

Surviving midlife with grace and dignity. And a little humor.

Hearts and Minds

Why choose.. lets go with both

My Journey by Grace

God giving me to share time & space

Almost Iowa

Where irrationality trumps reason

Chocolate Cocaine

Eroticism, Intimacy, Sex, Erotic Poetry, Erotic, Writer, Author, Spoken Word, Erotic Spoken Word, Erotic Artist, Sensuality, Erotic Artists Unite, Karma Eve, Chocolate Cocaine

Writer of Words etc

Words, mostly


...the journey continues

In Between Days

The musings of a 40 something who is still waiting on her happy ending and hoping he shows up a little disheveled and road-weary.

Wandering Explorer Travel

Thoughts & Memories of a Traveler at Heart

slave shae

My Submissive Journey in a Life of D/s Slavery

Raise Your Feathers

Your Mind, Your Story and You

Be Inspired..!!

Listen to your inner has all the answers..

Hopelessly Hopeless

Romance isn’t dead. It’s just overrated.

an inferior slut

18+ only | nsfw

Olivia Lucie Blake

Musings of a Millennial. Life, The World and Everything In Between.

Lillith Avir

D/s... mostly

Create your website with
Get started
%d bloggers like this: